If you’ve been burned by too many clutch hits or lost control of late-game leads, mastering your defensive strategy in MLB The Show 25 can make all the difference. While hitting often gets the spotlight, elite players know that shutting down rallies is just as important. Whether you're looking to improve your Diamond Dynasty lineup or grinding Ranked Seasons, these 11 defensive formations can help you prevent big plays and take control of the field.
1. Standard Alignment for Balanced Lineups
Sometimes less is more. Use the standard defensive setup when facing balanced hitters who don’t show a strong tendency to pull or push the ball. This is especially useful when you're unsure about tendencies and want to minimize risk.
2. Pull Shift (Infield)
When facing power hitters who consistently pull the ball, this formation stacks infielders on their pull side. It's ideal for preventing ground-ball base hits through the hole. Just be aware of slap hitters who might bunt against it.
3. Extreme Pull Shift (Infield & Outfield)
Going one step further, this aggressive shift can smother lefties like Joey Gallo who rarely go opposite field. Use this formation cautiously—one well-placed bunt or slap hit can break the alignment.
4. Double Play Depth
Perfect for situations with a runner on first and less than two outs. Your middle infielders play slightly deeper to increase their chance of turning two. It’s a small shift but can lead to big momentum swings.
5. Infield In
Used with a runner on third and fewer than two outs, this setup sacrifices range for the chance to cut off a run at the plate. Don’t overuse it, as well-hit grounders can easily sneak through.
6. No Doubles Outfield
Late in the game with a small lead? Shift your outfielders deeper and towards the lines. This reduces the risk of extra-base hits—just be ready to give up shallow singles.
7. Outfield Shift Right
If your scouting report shows a hitter spraying most fly balls to right, shift your outfield accordingly. This is a great way to prevent RBI doubles in clutch situations.
8. Corner In (Corners Infield)
This formation is great for bunters or squeeze play threats, especially with runners on third. Your corners charge in to cover the bunt, while your middle infield stays deep for flexibility.
9. Outfield In
If you’re in a must-stop situation—like bottom of the 9th with a runner on third—pulling your outfield in can help you cut off game-winning singles. Just beware of balls over the top.
10. Bunt Defense
Some players still love to cheese bunt their way on base. Use this pre-set to bring your corners in, ideal for defending against bunt-heavy lineups or speedy contact hitters.
11. Custom Shifts Based on Player Tendencies
The true pros in MLB The Show 25 take time to build custom defensive shifts. Watch tendencies and hot zones during matchups, and adjust accordingly. It’s a time investment, but it separates average players from the elite.
Don’t Let Defense Be Your Weakest Link
Building up your defense isn’t just about smart shifts—it also ties into player attributes. Strong fielders with high reaction ratings are more effective no matter the formation. Upgrading your roster is key, and you can buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to pick up elite defenders or make strategic acquisitions in the marketplace.
Players on mlb 25 stubs xbox marketplaces often rotate quickly, especially after major live content drops or roster updates. Keep an eye on prices and buy when value aligns with your team’s needs.
If you’re unsure where to start, platforms like U4N provide consistent access to MLB The Show 25 content and help players level up both offensively and defensively without wasting time or grinding endlessly.
By mixing these 11 formations into your game plan and keeping your roster sharp, you’ll start to see fewer bloop singles, fewer two-run doubles, and a lot more scoreboard control. Defense wins championships—even in MLB The Show 25.
